Forgotten Island vs One Terrible Day

Forgotten Island has the higher audience score (8.2/10 against 6.5/10 for One Terrible Day). One Terrible Day is the shorter watch at 18m compared with 1h 49m. One Terrible Day is the older of the two (1922 against 2026). Both are comedy, family movies, so they suit a similar mood.

Forgotten Island posterForgotten Island2026 VS One Terrible Day posterOne Terrible Day1922
Forgotten IslandOne Terrible Day
Audience score★ 8.2/10★ 6.5/10
Year20261922
Length1h 49m18m
GenresAdventure, Animation, Comedy, Family, FantasyComedy, Family
CountryUnited States of America–
DirectorJanuel Mercado, Joel CrawfordRobert F. McGowan, Tom McNamara
Main castH.E.R., Liza Soberano, Dave Franco, Jenny Slate, Manny JacintoJack Davis, Sunshine Sammy Morrison, Jackie Condon, Mickey Daniels, Allen 'Farina' Hoskins

Synopsis

Forgotten Island

While celebrating their last night together, high school graduates and best friends Jo and Raissa stumble upon a mysterious portal that transports them to the fantastical island of Nakali. When they discover that the memories of their entire friendship are the price for returning home, Jo and Raissa must race to find a way to leave the island before they forget each other forever.

One Terrible Day

Mrs. Pennington Van Renssalaer, a publicity-minded society matron, sponsors a children's outing, much to her and her chauffeur's eventual regret.

Where to watch

Where to watch Forgotten IslandWhere to watch One Terrible Day

More like Forgotten Island · More like One Terrible Day · Compare other titles