I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco vs The Killer Is Calling
The Killer Is Calling has the higher audience score (7.2/10 against 7/10 for I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco). The Killer Is Calling is the shorter watch at 1h 28m compared with 1h 30m. The Killer Is Calling is the older of the two (2025 against 2026). Both are thriller, tv movie movies, so they suit a similar mood.
I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco
The Killer Is Calling| I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco | The Killer Is Calling | |
|---|---|---|
| Audience score | ★ 7.0/10 | ★ 7.2/10 |
| Year | 2026 | 2025 |
| Length | 1h 30m | 1h 28m |
| Genres | Crime, Thriller, TV Movie | Thriller, TV Movie |
| Country | – | – |
| Director | Heather Hawthorn-Doyle | Craig Pryce |
| Main cast | Dillon Casey, Madelyn Grace, Indy Lesage, Amara Sanoy, Chloe Lanier | Rob Stewart, Janaya Stephens, Joe Pingue, Duane Keogh, Robert Bazzocchi |
Synopsis
I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco
For the first time ever, Mary Jo Buttafuoco tells her story in her own words. In May 1992, outside her Long Island home, Mary Jo was shot in the head by 17-year-old Amy Fisher — the mistress of her husband, Joey Buttafuoco.
The Killer Is Calling
When a mysterious killer targets her remote island town over the course of one long night, veteran 911 operator Faye must uncover his motives and try to save her community, one emergency call at a time.
Where to watch
Where to watch I Am Mary Jo ButtafuocoWhere to watch The Killer Is Calling
More like I Am Mary Jo Buttafuoco · More like The Killer Is Calling · Compare other titles