It Had to Be You vs The Love Hypothesis

The Love Hypothesis has the higher audience score (8.1/10 against 6/10 for It Had to Be You). It Had to Be You is the shorter watch at 1h 37m compared with 1h 52m. It Had to Be You is the older of the two (2000 against 2026). Both are comedy, romance movies, so they suit a similar mood.

It Had to Be You posterIt Had to Be You2000 VS The Love Hypothesis posterThe Love Hypothesis2026
It Had to Be YouThe Love Hypothesis
Audience score★ 6.0/10★ 8.1/10
Year20002026
Length1h 37m1h 52m
GenresComedy, RomanceComedy, Romance
Country–United States of America
DirectorSteven FederClaire Scanlon
Main castJoelle Carter, Natasha Henstridge, Michael Vartan, Michael Rispoli, Olivia d'AboLili Reinhart, Tom Bateman, Rachel Marsh, Jaboukie Young-White, Nicholas Duvernay

Synopsis

It Had to Be You

Sparks fly when Anna Penn and Charlie Hudson meet. Unfortunately, they're both engaged to other people. In fact, they're staying at the same New York City hotel in order to work on wrapping up the last details of their nuptials. Over days and evenings of joint wedding planning, the two grow closer -- and start to wonder if they're getting married to the right people after all.

The Love Hypothesis

Olive Smith, a biology PhD candidate, and Dr. Adam Carlsen, a hotshot professor and well-known tyrant, enter into a fake relationship, seeing each of their carefully calculated theories on love get thrown into chaos.

Where to watch

Where to watch It Had to Be YouWhere to watch The Love Hypothesis

More like It Had to Be You · More like The Love Hypothesis · Compare other titles