Magic Valley vs The French Italian

The French Italian has the higher audience score (10/10 against 6.1/10 for Magic Valley). Magic Valley is the shorter watch at 1h 25m compared with 1h 32m. Magic Valley is the older of the two (2011 against 2024). Both are drama movies, so they suit a similar mood.

Magic Valley posterMagic Valley2011 VS The French Italian posterThe French Italian2024
Magic ValleyThe French Italian
Audience score★ 6.1/10★ 10.0/10
Year20112024
Length1h 25m1h 32m
GenresDramaDrama
CountryUnited States of AmericaUnited States of America
DirectorJaffe ZinnRachel Wolther
Main castWill Estes, Alison Elliott, Johnny Lewis, Matthew Gray Gubler, Kyle GallnerJon Rudnitsky, Sunita Mani, Aristotle Athari, Catherine Cohen, Soojeong Son

Synopsis

Magic Valley

As one warm October day unfolds, the sleepy town of Buhl, Idaho will never be the same. A fish farmer finds his crop destroyed, a couple of kids are playing an unusual game in the sun-dappled fields, and after a wild party a sleepless teenager is harboring an awful secret….

The French Italian

Doug and Valerie have made a mistake. Their hate-fueled obsession with the jerks downstairs — who always seem to be singing karaoke in a brownstone, who even does that? — recently led them to flee the city for Doug’s parents’ place upstate, giving up a great deal on a rent-stabilized apartment. Their friends are horrified, and regret is setting in. They start plotting their revenge— and before they know it, they’re staging an off-Broadway play…

Where to watch

Where to watch Magic ValleyWhere to watch The French Italian

More like Magic Valley · More like The French Italian · Compare other titles