The Proposal vs What We Wanted to Be

What We Wanted to Be has the higher audience score (7.8/10 against 7.2/10 for The Proposal). What We Wanted to Be is the shorter watch at 1h 24m compared with 1h 48m. The Proposal is the older of the two (2009 against 2024). Both are comedy, drama, romance movies, so they suit a similar mood.

The Proposal posterThe Proposal2009 VS What We Wanted to Be posterWhat We Wanted to Be2024
The ProposalWhat We Wanted to Be
Audience score★ 7.2/10★ 7.8/10
Year20092024
Length1h 48m1h 24m
GenresComedy, Drama, RomanceComedy, Drama, Romance
Country–Argentina
DirectorAnne FletcherAlejandro Agresti
Main castMichael Mosley, Mary Steenburgen, Aasif Mandvi, Ryan Reynolds, Sandra BullockEleonora Wexler, Luis Rubio, Antonio Agresti, Carlos Gorosito

Synopsis

The Proposal

When she learns she's in danger of losing her visa status and being deported, overbearing book editor Margaret Tate forces her put-upon assistant, Andrew Paxton, to marry her.

What We Wanted to Be

An impossible love story that begins outside a movie theater, continues in a café and could end with the two protagonists together… if real life wasn’t much more complicated than the movies. United by their love of cinema, these two main characters decide to live the lives they dreamed of and not the lives they are destined to live. In a series of encounters, imagination triumphs over reality and everyday reality takes a back seat.

Where to watch

Where to watch The ProposalWhere to watch What We Wanted to Be

More like The Proposal · More like What We Wanted to Be · Compare other titles