Murder Island vs The Curious Case of...
The Curious Case of... has the higher audience score (9/10 against 5.5/10 for Murder Island). Murder Island is the older of the two (2021 against 2025). Both are crime, documentary shows, so they suit a similar mood.
Murder Island
The Curious Case of...| Murder Island | The Curious Case of... | |
|---|---|---|
| Audience score | ★ 5.5/10 | ★ 9.0/10 |
| Year | 2021 | 2025 |
| Seasons | 1 | 2 |
| Genres | Crime, Documentary, Mystery | Crime, Documentary |
| Country | – | US |
| Creator / director | – | – |
| Main cast | Parm Sandhu, Graham McMillan | Beth Karas |
Synopsis
Murder Island
Murder mystery with a twist - the investigators are members of the public, competing to find the killer and pocket themselves £50,000. The body of Charly Hendricks has been found at an old run-down property she was renting from the local pub landlord. It's up to four pairs of amateur sleuths to search the scene and unpick the clues, hoping to find a motive for the crime.
The Curious Case of...
Take a deep dive into real-life scandals, exposing bizarre secrets, shattered lives, and twisted motives. Led by Beth Karas, each gripping story uncovers deceit, greed, and manipulation, proving truth is far more chilling than fiction.
Where to watch
Where to watch Murder IslandWhere to watch The Curious Case of...
More like Murder Island · More like The Curious Case of... · Compare other titles