Movies like Return of the Tooth Fairy

If you enjoyed Return of the Tooth Fairy (2020), a horror movie, these 24 movies are the closest matches in our catalogue, starting with The Household, Attempted Murder, Livestream from Hell. They share its genres and are ranked by how many they have in common, then by audience score.

About Return of the Tooth FairyReturn of the Tooth Fairy vs The Household

1. 

   1. The Household (2025)

   ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

   Details & where to watchCompare

2. 

   2. Attempted Murder (2025)

   ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

   Details & where to watchCompare

3. 

   3. Livestream from Hell (2026)

   ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

   Details & where to watchCompare

4. 

   4. Boy Of Your Dreams 2 (2026)

   ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

   Details & where to watchCompare

5. 

   5. Tooth Fairy: Drill to Kill (2022)

   ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

   Details & where to watchCompare

6. 

   6. He's Watching You (2026)

   ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

   Details & where to watchCompare

7. 

   7. Contamination (2025)

   ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

   Details & where to watchCompare

8. 

   8. Soulm8te (2026)

   ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

   Details & where to watchCompare

9. 

   9. God of Frogs (2026)

   ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

   Details & where to watchCompare

10. 

    10. Romance Post-Mortem (2023)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

11. 

    11. Family (2026)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

12. 

    12. Night of Blood (2026)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

13. 

    13. The Ritual: Black Nun (2023)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

14. 

    14. My Baby (2023)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

15. 

    15. Bull Shark 3 (2025)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

16. 

    16. Parasomnia (2025)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

17. 

    17. Origin (2024)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

18. 

    18. Tinsman Road (2025)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

19. 

    19. The Devil's Mouth (2026)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

20. 

    20. Dr. Prim (2021)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

21. 

    21. Mass State Lottery (2025)

    ★ 9.5/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

22. 

    22. Evil Spirit (2016)

    ★ 9.5/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

23. 

    23. CHAT (2026)

    ★ 9.5/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

24. 

    24. Scurry (2025)

    ★ 9.5/10 · Shares: Horror

    Details & where to watchCompare

Narrow it down with the suggestion finder · Take the quiz