TV shows like Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries

If you enjoyed Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries (2026), a mystery show, these 24 TV shows are the closest matches in our catalogue, starting with Coven Academy, The Artist, Among Us. They share its genres and are ranked by how many they have in common, then by audience score.

About Sugarcreek Amish MysteriesSugarcreek Amish Mysteries vs Coven Academy

  1. Coven Academy poster

    1. Coven Academy (2026)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  2. The Artist poster

    2. The Artist (2025)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  3. Among Us poster

    3. Among Us (2026)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  4. Million-Follower Detective poster

    4. Million-Follower Detective (2026)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  5. Creepy Bits poster

    5. Creepy Bits (2021)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  6. Somebody's Hiding Something poster

    6. Somebody's Hiding Something (2023)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  7. Stolen Heartbeats poster

    7. Stolen Heartbeats (2026)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  8. The Apartment Job poster

    8. The Apartment Job (2026)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  9. Cooper & Fry poster

    9. Cooper & Fry (2025)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  10. City of Blood poster

    10. City of Blood (2026)

    ★ 10.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  11. Dare You to Death poster

    11. Dare You to Death (2025)

    ★ 9.9/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  12. The Art of Sarah poster

    12. The Art of Sarah (2026)

    ★ 9.5/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  13. Notes from the Last Row poster

    13. Notes from the Last Row (2026)

    ★ 9.2/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  14. The Scarecrow poster

    14. The Scarecrow (2026)

    ★ 9.2/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  15. Moral Peanuts poster

    15. Moral Peanuts (2010)

    ★ 9.1/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  16. First Department poster

    16. First Department (2020)

    ★ 9.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  17. The Long Watch poster

    17. The Long Watch (2026)

    ★ 9.0/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  18. Someday or One Day poster

    18. Someday or One Day (2019)

    ★ 8.9/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  19. Coroner's Diary poster

    19. Coroner's Diary (2025)

    ★ 8.9/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  20. GNOSIA poster

    20. GNOSIA (2025)

    ★ 8.8/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  21. The Apothecary Diaries poster

    21. The Apothecary Diaries (2023)

    ★ 8.7/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  22. Spider-Noir poster

    22. Spider-Noir (2026)

    ★ 8.7/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  23. Strange Days at Blake Holsey High poster

    23. Strange Days at Blake Holsey High (2002)

    ★ 8.7/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

  24. The Originals poster

    24. The Originals (2013)

    ★ 8.6/10 · Shares: Mystery

    Details & where to watchCompare

Narrow it down with the suggestion finder · Take the quiz